Back to browse
GrahamBell – If blockchain mining looked like this, would you mine?

GrahamBell – If blockchain mining looked like this, would you mine?

by HurairahShamsi·Apr 16, 2026·2 points·0 comments

AI Analysis

MidBig BrainBold Bet

Rate-limited mining prevents 51% attacks, but Sybil identity protection is missing.

Strengths
  • Novel consensus approach capping hash rate per node identity to slow attacks.
  • Working browser-based MVP demonstrates the mining mechanism and witness chain visually.
Weaknesses
  • Node identity is easily spoofed, undermining Sybil resistance and security claims.
  • No live network or economic security model beyond the local browser demonstration.
Target Audience

Blockchain researchers, crypto enthusiasts

Similar To

Bitcoin · Ethereum · Nano

Post Description

Hi HN,

I’ve been working on a blockchain design that takes a different approach to the 51% attack problem. Instead of making attacks instantly expensive through hardware or capital (as in traditional systems), it makes them structurally slow to execute, which in turn makes them costly and difficult to sustain over time.

The core idea is simple: (1) Each node/identity is limited to ~1 hash/sec in the Proof-of-Work process, regardless of hardware (2) Remove parallel mining advantages (no work is sharable) (3) Shift influence toward sustained persistent participation rather than raw hashpower (4) Make generating sybil identities (in bulk) slow, costly, and difficult.

I’ve built a browser-based MVP demonstrating the capped PoW model (as a reference implementation): https://grahambell.io/mvp/Proof_of_Witness.html

There’s also a short demo here (Capped PoW) : https://youtu.be/i5gzzqFXXUk?si=y_Pv5ZDv9SGhRFjY

Website: https://grahambell.io/

Curious whether the approach sounds interesting, or immediately broken to you.

Peace

Similar Projects

1Hash/Sec/Node PoW During A/V Calls, No Parallel Mining and P2P Telecom

The site ships an interactive simulation where you can start ‘mining’, tweak nonces, tamper with fields and watch blocks be accepted or rejected in real time — a neat educational sandbox for a novel ASIC‑resistance idea. It’s a focused MVP: the Proof of Witness + Witness Chains concept is intriguing, but the demo reads as a concept validation rather than a full P2P/telco implementation (security hardening and real-world networking are explicitly missing).

Bold BetBig BrainShip It
HurairahShamsi
313mo ago
Open Source●●Solid

Phonchain – A Mobile-Native Blockchain Secured by Smartphones (Pop-S4)

The project actually publishes canonical genesis anchors, protocol specs, bootstrap endpoints and a live explorer — so this reads like a working protocol, not just vaporware. The core idea (PoP-S4.1: up to ~30k phones per block) is a bold, unusual approach to consensus, but the repo shows little community traction and lacks obvious public audits or transparent attestation primitives, so treat the live network with healthy skepticism until security details and client code are clearer.

Bold BetWizardryNiche Gem
PHONCOIN
113mo ago